Categories: Pakistan

SC moved against Justice Tariq’s inclusion in civilians’ mily trials case

F.P. Report

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan (SC) was Monday moved against the inclusion of Justice Tariq Masood’s inclusion in the bench slated to hear the intra-court appeals against the top court’s verdict annulling civilians’ trials in military courts.

Justice Masood heads the six-member SC bench that will take up multiple pleas filed by the federal government, Ministry of Defence, and provincial governments of Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and Balochistan on December 13 against the SC verdict that declared the trials of civilians in military courts as “null and void”.

The federal government, following the May 9 riots — erupted after the arrest of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI)-then chairman Imran Khan — which saw military installations being vandalised across the country, had announced to hold military trials of those allegedly involved in the riots. However, multiple petitions were filed in the SC by Imran, Aitzaz Ahsan, Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research (Piler) Executive Director Karamat Ali, and former chief justice of Pakistan Jawwad S Khawaja against the military trials of civilians.

On October 23, a five-member apex court bench headed by Justice Ijaz Ul Ahsan unanimously admitted the aforesaid pleas and nullified the government’s decision to try civilians in military courts. Following the SC verdict, federal and provincial governments along with the defence ministry filed intra-court appeals (ICAs) against the said verdict.

In his petition filed today, ex-justice Khawaja contends that Justice Masood had already expressed his views on the said matter — non-maintainability of the petitions filed against civilians’ military trials — via his written note and so must recuse himself from the bench from hearing the pleas filed against the SC verdict.

“These four petitions have been filed by those who apparently are not detained, nor facing trial with regard to the offences, allegedly committed on 9th May 2023 […] The said persons had attacked, destroyed and/or burnt public property and the property of the armed forces […] If a law is challenged, usually, it is before the High Court under Article 199 of the Constitution however these petitions have been filed in this court under Article 184 (3) of the Constitution which jurisdiction can only be invoked in the public interest for the enforcement of fundamental rights,” Justice Masood’s note had read.

Khawaja’s petition further argues that since Justice Masood considers the petitions “unusual”, it indicates “a predisposition which compromises, possibly substantively and certainly as a matter of perception, independent and unbiased adjudication.” It also contends that Masood, in his note, found that each case has to be considered on facts, he therefore, reached the conclusion that the petitions against civilians’ military trial were not maintainable under Article 184(3) of the Constitution.

Stressing that a judge who has, without hearing the parties, made a public and written finding in respect of a specific issue between the parties, the plea highlights that it would not be fair for Justice Masood to hear this matter. In his petition, the former judge has called for Justice Masood to recuse himself from the said case and not head the bench in the interest of justice, and to refer the matter back to the committee constituted under the Supreme Court Practice and Procedure Act 2023 for reconstitution of the bench which is to hear the ICAs.

The Frontier Post

Recent Posts

India poll watchdog’s inaction lets PM Modi commit ‘brazen’ violations, opposition says

NEW DELHI (Reuters) : India's opposition said the nation's election commission was allowing Prime Minister…

28 mins ago

Hundreds evacuated from Ukraine border after Russian offensive

KYIV (AFP) : Hundreds of people were evacuated from areas near the Russian border in…

60 mins ago

Australia, New Zealand back Palestinian statehood in UN vote

ADELAIDE (AA) : Australia and New Zealand joined other countries in backing Palestinian statehood in…

1 hour ago

Israel orders new evacuations in Rafah as it prepares to expand operations

RAFAH, Gaza Strip (AP) : Israel ordered new evacuations in Gaza’s southern city of Rafah…

1 hour ago

Pyongyang to deploy new multiple rocket launcher this year: KCNA

SEOUL (AFP) : North Korea will equip its military with a new 240mm multiple rocket launcher…

1 hour ago

UNGA backs Palestinian bid for membership

UNITED NATIONS (APP): The United Nations General Assembly Friday voted, by an overwhelming majority, to…

15 hours ago

This website uses cookies.