Gabriel Levin
Former President Donald Trump, the front-runner for the Republican Party’s 2024 presidential nomination, will be a no-show at the third candidates debate Wednesday night in Florida, opting instead to host an event nearby. But five other conservative presidential hopefuls will be looking for breakthroughs.
Wednesday’s debate will be broadcast live from the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts of Miami-Dade County from 8 to 10 p.m. Eastern time on NBC News and Rumble, a livestreaming platform. Since the first Republican debate in Milwaukee more than two months ago, former Vice President Mike Pence has left the race and former Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson and Governor Doug Burgum of North Dakota have been swept aside, having raised too little money to qualify for Wednesday night’s forum.
Those still in contention – and willing to show up to the debate – are Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, biotech businessman Vivek Ramaswamy, former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley, former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie and US Senator Tim Scott of South Carolina. Here’s what to know about the candidates’ positions on key issues that are likely to come up.
There are two competing approaches to foreign policy to look for tonight: hawkish neoconservativism from Haley and isolationism – Trump’s brand of diplomacy that Ramaswamy and DeSantis seem to be mimicking. Haley sees military aid to Israel and Ukraine as crucial to preserving Western interests abroad. Scott and Christie agree that helping Israel and Ukraine in their war efforts is crucial. Ramaswamy, on the other hand, wants out of what he calls “no-win wars” and recently said the US’s job is not “to be the global police.” To Ramaswamy, successful foreign policy means cutting off many US allies from support.
DeSantis has similarly argued that helping Ukraine’s counteroffensive is not a priority, echoing Trump’s controversial “America first” stance. Super political action committees for Haley and DeSantis have repeatedly aired campaign ads accusing each other of being too easy on China. Those ads leveled claims that fact-checkers have called into doubt, including that Haley allowed a Chinese corporation to “get dangerously close” to a US Army base and another that “DeSantis voted to fast-track” Obama-era trade deals with China. Expect Haley and DeSantis to defend themselves and spar over their views on China and more.
Progressives made inroads in state-level elections Tuesday in winning back abortion rights, which the US Supreme Court returned to the states’ purview when it struck down Roe v. Wade in June 2022. Some states have greatly restricted abortion rights since then. The Republican candidates differ in their views on abortion. Haley, DeSantis and Scott would sign a nationwide ban on abortions after 15 weeks. They haven’t said whether they would allow exceptions in instances of rape or incest or when a pregnancy could be fatal.
Ramaswamy and Christie, while both personally against abortions, have said that they would not support a federal ban, citing the 10th Amendment to the US Constitution, which some legal scholars say gives decision-making authority over abortion bans to the states. Ramaswamy has advocated for six-week abortion bans at the state level but said he wouldn’t use executive authority to impose them. Both Ramaswamy and Christie support exceptions in instances of rape or incest or when a pregnancy could be fatal.
As governor of Florida, DeSantis helped outlaw mifepristone, a hormone-blocking drug that is used in medication abortions. Haley has said the legality of mifepristone should be decided by elected officials at the state level. Ramaswamy, Christie and Scott haven’t elaborated their positions on mifepristone.
Ramaswamy, himself the child of immigrants, has perhaps the harshest policies on immigration. He has said that he would deport every undocumented immigrant and deploy the military at the southern US border to halt any more mass crossings. Haley has said she would make it more difficult for undocumented immigrants to find jobs and that immigration officials should carry out deportations. DeSantis has said he would deport undocumented immigrants, particularly those who overstay their visas or are found guilty of crimes. In Florida, he clamped down on undocumented immigration. Scott has supported bringing back Title 42, which forces out migrants without any legal proceedings, but hasn’t said whether he would deport undocumented immigrants.
Of all the contenders, Ramaswamy has been the least critical of Trump. As Haley and DeSantis vie for second place, expect them to make their cases for why Republican voters should want them over Trump. DeSantis hasn’t said whether he thinks human activity is the main cause of climate change. Haley, Christie and Scott, however, have. Ramaswamy has said that human activity causing climate change is probable but has never expressed certainty. Ramaswamy and Scott have publicly doubted that climate change is making natural disasters more lethal, with Ramaswamy having said at the first Republican debate that “the climate change agenda is a hoax.” All the candidates who will take the stage at tonight’s debate have said that the market is better suited than the government to handle climate change. DeSantis, Haley, Ramaswamy and Scott are opposed to rebate programs for drivers of clean-energy vehicles. Christie hasn’t given his position on tax credits yet.
If the impacts of climate change come up, expect Ramaswamy to be the most vocal denier as in previous debates. All the candidates who will appear at tonight’s debate are against restricting access to firearms for those who might pose threats to themselves or others. They also oppose expanding background checks, except for Ramaswamy, who hasn’t yet made his opinions on that known. Of all the topics that might come up tonight, what to do – or not to do – about gun violence will likely be among the least contentious for the candidates, who broadly see eye to eye on the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms.
VOA
