What we learned from all the rockets we lost in 2020

Monitoring Desk

Launching rockets is hard. Most of the time we get it right, but sometimes unexpected things happen. Perhaps it’s because of a stage failure or perhaps it’s because of using a daring prototype, like SpaceX’s Starship. But, as devastating as a failure can feel, it can help the teams behind these launches to learn and grow, helping them to continue to improve spaceflight. 

Below is a list of the craziest rocket explosions and failures of 2020 (not including situations where a rocket had an anomaly en route but was still able to reach orbit (such as SpaceX’s Falcon 9 Starlink rocket launch of March 18) or the numerous launch aborts of 2020 due to situations like weather or technical issues).

SpaceX's Third Starship Prototype Collapsed Last Night - Universe Today
Universe Today

1) Starship SN3 prototype explosion

SpaceX’s Starship SN3 was supposed to do a series of tests in the spring that would end with short “hopping” test flights. However, a problem during one of the tests in April caused the prototype to blow up. At the time, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk suggested there may have been a “test configuration mistake” (which was later found to be leaky valves) that led to the vehicle’s cryogenic pressure test failing. SpaceX wanted to see if SN3 could withstand the high pressure of super-cold fuel required to send it on flights.

2) Starship SN4 prototype explosion

SpaceX’s Starship SN4 prototype also exploded this past May in a dramatic fireball. The explosion happened about one minute after the Raptor rocket engine was tested. That said, SN4 had already lasted through four static-fire engine tests and only ran into problems on its fifth, making it the longest-lived and most-tested Starship at the time. The early testing on SN4 was meant to help with eventual flight readiness for Starship, which took more meaning in the spring after NASA selected Starship as one of the spacecraft to land people on the moon for the agency’s Artemis program.

SpaceX's Starship SN4 prototype explodes on the test stand - Neowin

3) Starship SN7 prototype explosion

The next Starship prototype, called SN7, also ruptured during a pressure test in June — a deliberate explosion as SpaceX was testing the limits for the fuel tank. The tank was filled past its capacity with super-chilled liquid nitrogen before bursting. Deliberately pushing parts to failure is a normal part of the spacecraft (and aerospace) industry, because it creates hard data on how far you can push the vehicle during normal operations. In the long term, such testing leads to fewer failures and improved safety.

Another Starship Test Ends in an Explosion (Intentionally This Time) -  Universe Today
Universe Today

4) Starship SN8 prototype explosion

Click here for more Space.com videos…SpaceX Starship SN8’s epic flight – See multiple amazing viewsVolume 0%PLAY SOUND

The next and last Starship prototype of 2020, named SN8, took to the air for several minutes in December before flipping around and eventually exploding upon landing. While the prototype didn’t stick the landing, it did last through several aerial maneuvers, including a “belly flop” similar to what Starship will do during operational flights. CEO Elon Musk appeared elated with the prototype progress, declaring: “Mars, here we come!” in a tweet.

SpaceX's 16-story-tall Starship prototype explodes on landing after test  launch | Daily Sabah
Saily Sabah

5) Northrop Grumman OmegA cancellation

Northrop Grumman was still working on test firing its new OmegA rocket in February, but the program was not planned to last through the year. The company elected to not move forward with the program after the U.S. Space Force didn’t include OmegA on its list of potential national security launch contractors, according to Florida Today

While the OmegA program itself is no more, Northrop Grumman plans to use the lessons learned from this program in other company activities and business lines.

Northrop Grumman touts financial strength in marketing pitch for OmegA  rocket - SpaceNews
Space News

6) Iran’s Zafar-1

Iran’s communication satellite, Zafar 1, didn’t make it to orbit due to a rocket problem during launch in February. The first stage of the launch aboard the Simorgh rocket went to plan, but the satellite didn’t pick up enough speed to get in orbit, Defense Ministry space program spokesman Ahmad Hosseini told Iranian state television, according to the Associated Press. Iran had been working through a few rocket failures before this one, including a Simorgh launch failure in January 2019 and another rocket failure (the Safir) in February 2019. Another rocket from Iran appears to have exploded in August 2019, according to satellite footage from San Francisco-based company Planet.

Iran Official, Photos Suggest A US-Criticized Satellite Launch Looms
Radio Farda English

7) China Long March rocket failures

At least two of China’s long-running Long March rockets failed during launches in 2020. One failure in March took place with a new version of the rocket, called Long March 7A, which was on its rookie launch. 

Weeks later in April, a rocket from the veteran Long March 3B booster line failed to launch an Indonesian satellite. Despite these failures, China did stay active with launching for most of 2020.

China's launch of Long March-5 Y2 rocket fails - YouTube
YouTube: China’s launch of Long March-5 Y2 rocket fails

8) China’s Kuaizhou rocket failures

China’s Kuaizhou rocket also had two launch failures in 2020. The first problem took place in July, when a Kuaizhou-11 rocket (on the first-ever flight for that rocket type) failed after appearing to successfully launch and separate its first and second stages. Later in September, a Kuaizhou-1A rocket also experienced a problem during launch, according to SpaceNews. On both occasions, China briefly acknowledged the failure publicly and said the cause would be investigated.

People's Daily, China on Twitter: "Optical remote-sensing #satellite  Jilin-1 Gaofen 02C, which was launched aboard the Kuaizhou-1A carrier rocket  in NW China on Saturday, failed to enter the preset orbit. Cause of

9) Virgin Orbit’s LauncherOne 

Virgin Orbit had a problem during its test flight of the LauncherOne rocket, which failed to separate from its carrier plane, in May. The California-based company successfully performed several test flights before releasing the rocket on a failed effort to take a dummy payload to low Earth orbit. Virgin Orbit later said an anomaly of LauncherOne’s NewtonThree engine caused the problem. 

Virgin Orbit is now planning a new test launch called Demo 2, which will carry 10 CubeSats aloft; the mission has been delayed indefinitely from its December launch date due to the coronavirus pandemic reducing staffing levels, Virgin Orbit said on Twitter in December.

Virgin Orbit's LauncherOne: photos show the rocket attached to a 747 plane  - The Verge
The Verge

10) Rocket Lab’s Electron

New Zealand-based company Rocket Lab had a problem with the second stage of an Electron rocket in July that led to the loss of all seven small satellites aboard. Within weeks, Rocket Lab finished its investigation and said the failure happened due to a single faulty electrical connection in the rocket’s upper stage

The company recovered and successfully finished four more launches in 2020, closing out the year with the launch of a Japanese Earth-imaging satellite in December.

Rocket Lab's Electron Rocket | Space

11) Astra’s first orbital test flight

California-based startup Astra experienced a problem during what was supposed to be its first orbital mission. The booster lifted off successfully, but the rocket’s guidance failed during the firing of its first stage, Astra said in September

The company reached space successfully during a second test flight in December, but failed to reach orbit because the upper stage of Rocket 3.2 wasn’t going quite fast enough. Following a few more engineering adjustments, Astra plans to send its first paying flight into space in 2021.

Astra's 1st orbital launch attempt scuttled by wayward boat | Space

12) Arianespace’s Vega 

Arianespace saw the second failure of its Vega rocket in November, when its booster failed to bring satellites for Spain and France into orbit. The rocket ignited its upper stage, Avum, but the booster veered off course roughly eight minutes into flight and lost contact with ground stations. 

Arianespace said the likely cause was “a problem related to the integration of the fourth-stage AVUM nozzle activation system is the most likely cause of the loss of control of the launcher.” The investigation is ongoing and Vega’s return-to-flight date has not yet been announced.

Falcon Eye 1 spacecraft lost in Vega mishap - SpaceFlight Insider
Spaceflight Insider

13) Japan’s Interstellar Technologies

Private Japanese company Interstellar Technologies had an issue with its Momo-F5 sounding rocket that caused it to crash shortly after ignition in June. The crowdfunded rocket had an anomaly that forced Interstellar Technologies to send an abort command 70 seconds after launch, and the rocket crashed into the Pacific Ocean.

The maximum altitude of 7.1 miles (11.5 kilometers) during the mission was well short of its goal of 62 miles (100 km), an internationally recognized boundary of space.

Japan's Latest Attempt at Private Spaceflight Explodes on Liftoff | Fortune

Courtesy: Space.com